Hope for the Internet

Am I wrong for being hopeful for the future of the internet?

Right now the internet, as we have known it, and is not in a great state.

Google, which has largely been the gatekeeper to everything else, has become borderline unusable in the way it used to be.

All the old giants of social media are creaking and buckling under their own weight and no longer serving their primary use of connecting with friends.

Even Reddit, which people have been using as their primary way to search for information now Google only returns SEO optimized junk, is quickly degrading as the company is being taken public

We are fast approaching the acceleration point and peak of the great enshitification of the internet.

This should feel profoundly depressing but I find an optimism coming to me about it all easily.

Like mushrooms in the forest, the decay and rot of the giants are fueling the rise of small saplings.

A thing’s current state is often not as important as its trajectory. And I think there are signs the internet is changing it’s trajectory.

People are beginning to stop waiting for the large corporate entities to change and instead a growing number of tech engineers are trying to build new things.

For example I recently caught the 404media article on Stract (LINK) where someone started making an index of the internet in their basement for their own open source search engine.

I tried it out and it’s how Google used to be. When searching for terms it showed me so many unique and wonderful Indy blogs and small pages.

It let me discover things. Not just find what I wanted.

And speaking of Indy blogs, the return of long form blogs seems to be on the rise, somewhat round about in people doing them as newsletters first with the blog as the supporting feature, but my feed reader catalogue has been growing a lot faster lately.

Same too on social media fronts. Activitypub services are steadily growing, and even existing entities like Flipboard are adding federation, and the BBC development department reporting they may add activitypub federation in the future.

Small, independently hosted services supported by their user donations and not VC money or Ad revenue are popping up everywhere.

Same too with reddit, which for all it’s social issues seems to be the current resource for a lot of instructional and troubleshooting knowledge, has seen a large number of its forums migrating or mirroring onto Lemmy. Another small scale federating service propped up by user donations.

I think this shift in the funding model is important.

The main driver for enshitification is the profit model. Services don’t have to be good, they just have to generate ever more shareholder value.

Having small, financially sustainable entities become the backbone of the web instead wards against that.

I’m aware this may make me sound like an accelerationist. I don’t believe things getting so bad is necessary for things to improve. But in this instance I do think we are seeing positive things come out of the current decay.

Like mushrooms growing from fallen trees.