The Difficulty of Defining a Positive Masculinity

One of the highlights of the last year for me has been the discovery of the MensLib sub on Reddit. The space is welcoming, open-minded, pro-feminist and delightfully free of the horrible things the so-called ‘men’s rights’ groups are known for.

I had honestly given up hope of finding any sort of forum like this, a space for men to come together and talk about issues that negatively affect men stemming from toxic masculinity, and to try and collectively create a framework for a positive, nurturing masculinity.

Trying to define a positive masculinity

The topic of what positive masculinity would look like is a common one. Threads asking for positive role models in fiction, for book recommendations and general talk about what qualities make up positive masculinity are often topics of discussion.

This makes a lot of sense as we have very few cultural scripts to follow for non-aggressive masculinity. Women have fought hard to redefine their roles in society, and as such the narrow band of accepted cultural roles for women has expanded (in theory at least, there is still plenty of structural pressure pushing back against this)

For men, however, their available roles have remained far more stagnant. It became acceptable for women to wear pants, but not for men to put on makeup. Even the idea of men’s clothes that aren’t grey, black or earth tones is seen as bold.

Why men need to define it for themselves

This is of course because the feminist movement pushed for these changes and boar the brunt of the backlash.

The new social script for men needs to come from men. We have to be the ones to redefine our role in society. The trouble comes when trying to attribute any quality to something inherently masculine. The question always immediately follows: why is this quality inherently masculine?

This is all based on societal expectations rooted in gender essentialism. That there are qualities inherently male or female.

I don’t believe this. It’s a grand lie much of our society is built atop. But with so much of our social reality, so many people acting as if they are true gives them an weight in the world.

So when trying to create a positive social script for men, it needs to be done with an understanding that any good qualities ascribed to masculinity, say non-aggressive strength, aren’t inherently masculine. It is just that the problem of Toxic forms of masculinity is easier to deal with in short term. The work of slowly peeling back and changing the layers of gender essentialist assumptions in our society will take far, far longer to achieve.